GRAND VALLEY LAKES
BOARD MEETING — FULL DISCUSSION RECORD
Prepared from the Voice Memo transcript provided for the meeting record
Record note: This document preserves the substance and chronology of the supplied transcription. Obvious speech-to-text errors have been cleaned up where the intended meaning is reasonably clear. Speaker names are used only when identifiable from the transcript; where a speaker could not be reliably identified, the record uses a generic speaker designation rather than guessing.
- Ron Scott — President
- Billy Williams — Vice President
- Donna McClarin — Treasurer
- Amanda Martin — Secretary (made effective during this meeting)
- Carroll Huffman
- Patrick Conway
- Wayne Kneipp
- Paul Benoit
- David West
1. Call to Order, Prayer, and Pledge
The meeting was called to order. The presiding officer asked whether everyone could hear and opened the meeting with prayer.
The opening prayer thanked God for the gift of life, for the opportunity to serve others and the people of Grand Valley, and asked for guidance, love, and the ability to work together.
The Pledge of Allegiance was then recited.
2. Quorum and Absences
The presiding officer stated that a quorum was present. David West and Paul were identified as directors who were excused/not present.
3. Adoption of Agenda
The board was asked to review the agenda for additions or changes. No additions or changes were raised.
Motion: A motion was made to accept the agenda as written.
Second: A second was made.
Vote: The motion was approved by the board. No opposition was recorded.
4. Adoption of Previous Meeting Minutes
The previous meeting minutes had been prepared by Carol and were provided in the board members’ meeting books. The board was asked whether there were any questions or corrections.
Motion: A motion was made to approve/adopt the minutes of the previous meeting.
Second: A second was made.
Vote: The motion passed unanimously, with no opposition recorded.
5. Treasurer’s Report
Donna presented the Treasurer’s Report. The transcription contains several figures that are difficult to interpret because of speech-to-text errors. The figures that could be reasonably understood included approximately $30,822, approximately $7,000 associated with the fifth item, water income of approximately $27,305, and a total income figure of approximately $404,745. The transcript also references expenses of approximately $224,966.
Reported account balances included approximately $288,772 in the dues/general fund, approximately $34,821 in water, $56,126 in regular savings, approximately $380,478 in the water reserve, approximately $1,144 in water deposits, and approximately $10,400 in a water-related account/reserve. The amenities balance in the general fund was reported as approximately $5,306. A further approximately $76,000 had been collected but had not yet been transferred and was expected to be transferred to the water account.
The Treasurer indicated that the board was still determining how some of the collected amounts should be classified or transferred.
Motion: A motion was made to accept the Treasurer’s Report as presented.
Second: A second was made.
Vote: The motion carried, and the Treasurer’s Report was accepted and entered into the minutes.
6. President’s Report / Board Changes
The president asked for assistance with portions of the President’s Report and assigned portions of the report to other board members.
The board discussed upcoming board changes. Paul and Lisa are moving to Florida. Paul is currently serving as secretary. The secretary position transferred from Paul Benoit to Amanda Martin during this meeting. Paul is expected to remain on the board in a coaching/support capacity because he manages the website and a number of technical functions for the community.
Amanda was welcomed into the secretary role, with the president clarifying that she is already serving on the board and that the change is the secretary position.
7. Community Cleanup
Carol reported on the upcoming community cleanup scheduled for the following Saturday.
A neighbor offered a dump truck and another truck for the cleanup. The goal was to begin early Saturday morning and have everything delivered to the landfill before noon. The cleanup included a complete lot cleanup that had been scheduled.
Approximately ten volunteers had offered to help, with volunteers coming from the mobile-home section. Additional volunteers were being organized and scheduled. Residents needing help carrying items out were asked to contact Carol so additional volunteers could be assigned to those locations.
The group expected to meet near the restaurant early in the morning and work through the mobile-home section and other scheduled areas. A Facebook post would be used to communicate the schedule and meeting information.
Backup vehicles and trailers were discussed in case the primary truck could not participate. The board confirmed that the collected materials would be taken to the landfill and that the community would pay the associated disposal costs.
8. Algae / Lake Treatment and Water Concerns
The board discussed the upcoming lake treatment by Jones Lake Management. Treatment was expected on either Wednesday or Thursday, pending confirmation from the lake-management company.
Residents could sign up in the office for individual dock treatment. The reported cost was $125 per dock, consistent with the prior year. The sign-up period was expected to remain open through the following Tuesday. Residents receiving individual dock treatment might be asked to place a notice on the dock indicating that it was scheduled for treatment.
The board discussed the smaller lake. Jones Lake Management was expected to determine whether its boat could be launched there and, if not, the community might need to purchase chemicals and address treatment of the smaller lake separately.
Residents were asked whether anyone regularly kayaks or canoes on the smaller lake and could provide an assessment of algae conditions. The board noted that the smaller lake flows into the larger lake, making the condition of the smaller lake relevant to the larger lake.
A resident questioned why individual dock treatment was being charged to residents if the lake itself was also being treated. The board explained that the community would treat the lake generally with chemicals, while individual dock treatment would provide more concentrated or immediate treatment around a particular dock. The board acknowledged the concern that residents who pay the additional $125 should receive the additional attention associated with that service.
The board discussed whether treatment should ultimately be funded from a water reserve or through another community-wide funding mechanism so that lake treatment could benefit all residents, including residents who do not choose individual dock treatment.
The president stated that future budgets would allocate additional funds for lake treatment. The immediate individual treatment option was being offered in response to residents who specifically requested it.
9. E. coli / Lake Water Discussion
Residents raised concerns about E. coli and possible sewage entering the lake. Questions were asked about whether the lake water was safe, whether older septic or gray-water systems could be contributing, and whether known problems had been addressed.
The board discussed that E. coli can be present in lake water from animal sources and runoff and that the community moves a large volume of water through the spillway. It was stated that many homes have sewage systems and, in some cases, older gray-water systems.
The board acknowledged that at least one property had a known leak or wastewater-related issue that was being addressed. The president stated that the state had been involved and routinely communicates with the community regarding the lake.
A resident questioned why, if concerns had existed for some time, action had not occurred sooner. The board responded that it would not be accurate to say nothing had been done and stated that the matter was being addressed.
The board emphasized that the presence of some E. coli in a lake does not automatically mean the lake is unsafe and that natural runoff and wildlife can contribute bacteria. The discussion also distinguished possible wastewater runoff from the much broader exposure associated with people swimming in the lake.
Residents expressed concern for children and grandchildren using the lake. The board acknowledged those concerns and stated that it wanted residents to have accurate information and understand what was being done.
10. Long-Term Algae and Sediment Plan
The board described a multi-part approach to algae management: chemical treatment, individual dock treatment for residents who choose it, and the addition of grass carp.
Jones Lake Management had recommended adding approximately 920 grass carp in the fall. The board stated that it was too warm to add them immediately and that the fall stocking was intended to provide a longer-term biological control of vegetation.
The board discussed possible causes of algae and vegetation growth, including fertilizer runoff, sediment runoff, retaining walls and shoreline conditions, and the increasing shallowness of some coves. It was noted that some residents had observed sediment accumulation of several inches in certain coves.
The board discussed whether sediment could be removed or dredged. The discussion noted that state rules may limit removal of material from the lake, and the board agreed that additional information was needed before pursuing any such work.
Native grasses and other methods of reducing runoff were discussed. The president emphasized that the algae problem was not a one-time issue and that the community needed a one- to three-year plan addressing lake health, sediment, runoff, and vegetation.
The board had contacted TDEC and other agencies/organizations for guidance and was waiting for additional information.
Residents were encouraged to avoid unnecessary fertilizer runoff near the lake and to consider the effect of feeding fish and other activities that may contribute nutrients.
11. Mooring Buoy and No-Wake Areas
The board discussed a mooring buoy to be placed near the marina in an area where boats had been tying off on a no-wake buoy. The purpose of the mooring buoy is to give boaters a designated place to tie off without using the no-wake marker.
The board also reminded residents that no-wake zones apply to all motorized watercraft, including jet skis. Residents were asked to educate guests and younger riders about the lake rules.
Committee clarification: Jim Gehringer serves on the Architectural Review Committee and is not a board member.
12. Architectural Review Committee (ARC)
Jim Gehringer reported that the committees are still working through areas of overlapping responsibility and clarifying which committee has authority over various matters.
The ARC discussed a recent driveway connection and the need for contractors bringing heavy trucks, gravel, or other equipment into the community to coordinate with the office and ARC. The gate should not admit such activity without proper ARC/site-plan coordination.
A double-wide mobile home had arrived at a property without the expected prior coordination. The board determined that the addition itself was appropriate and looked good, but the contractor had failed to submit the required site plan in advance. The resident apparently believed the contractor had completed the process.
The board discussed the need for a clarification letter identifying which matters require prior approval and who is responsible for different approvals. Jim agreed to work toward having the clarification completed before the next board meeting.
The board also discussed sending a reminder to all residents to review the community’s covenants and rules, including the provisions governing construction, contractors, and property improvements.
13. Finance Committee
Donna reported that the Finance Committee continues to discuss possible changes to the community’s financial structure and potential proposals that might be presented to the membership. Various ways of raising or increasing revenue were discussed as an ongoing matter. No final proposal had been prepared for membership action.
14. Community Involvement Committee
Amanda Martin reported that the Community Involvement Committee is investigating fundraising opportunities and activities that could benefit the neighborhood. The committee remains in the planning stage and is evaluating different approaches before presenting proposals.
One idea being considered is hosting a 5K in the community. Another is holding a food-truck event periodically, potentially monthly or less frequently, to provide additional dining options and community gathering opportunities.
Donna had spoken with the Hardeman County mayor regarding a senior-citizen program. The community may be able to offer the lodge as a location for that program.
The committee has subcommittees involving the marina and gym. The committee also referenced prior resident surveys in which residents had identified amenities they would like to see, including a kayak launch into the smaller lake.
A resident owns a kayak launch that normally costs approximately $1,500 and is willing to sell it to the community for $300. The committee is investigating whether this would be an appropriate and useful addition.
15. Gym / Fitness Facility
Amanda reported that she had consulted with a kinesiologist regarding equipment appropriate for a facility of the gym’s size. The gym was generally close to the expected equipment level, although some equipment may be missing or need upgrading.
A person inspected the gym subfloor because of previous concerns about the effect of dropped or stored weights. The inspector reported that the subfloor was in excellent condition considering the age of the building.
The committee nevertheless decided that rubber flooring underneath the weight-equipment area would be beneficial for sound reduction and protection from impact. Pricing options were being obtained.
The committee has started an equipment wish list for future upgrades and additions. The list is intended as a planning tool because the current budget does not support replacing all equipment at once.
The committee also discussed adding paperwork or an acknowledgment before annual gym access codes are issued, reminding users to clean up after themselves and return weights to the rack so the next user does not have to move excessively heavy equipment.
16. Marina / Donations / Equipment
Amanda reported that Glenn donated money and Marvin Huffman donated labor to construct a new ramp leading to the marina.
An independent donor donated a new picnic table for the end of the marina. The committee discussed the need to secure or lower the umbrella at the picnic table so it does not blow into the lake and potentially become lost.
New bumpers/stoppers for the sides of the marina walkout were donated/ordered to help protect boats when entering and exiting. Installation was still pending.
The picnic tables currently at the end of the landing are expected to be moved to Tom’s shop for eventual use in the Green Space Park. The existing frames can be reused, with new wood needed.
A resident asked about responsibility for damage involving boats and marina equipment. The board discussed the issue and acknowledged that it needed additional research, including whether boat-owner insurance should be required.
17. Parking Near the Lake / Levee
A resident raised concerns about cars parking on both sides of the road near the lake/levee, creating a narrow passage for vehicles and raising safety concerns because children and dogs are in the area.
The board stated that parking should not occur on both sides of the road and discussed whether additional no-parking signs should be installed. Existing designated parking areas across the road and nearby were discussed.
The board agreed to look into additional parking options, including nearby community-owned land, and determine whether additional signs or enforcement were needed.
18. Maintenance Report
Maintenance reported that mulching had begun along road edges to improve visibility and clean up roadside areas. Work had been completed on portions of Grand Valley Drive and Golf Drive, with additional areas scheduled.
Additional trimming was planned in locations where vegetation was reducing sight distance around curves.
Tom had repaired several significant water leaks during the week, including leaks on India Lane and Teton. The board recognized the difficult conditions involved in making these repairs.
A review had been conducted of the community’s maintenance equipment and its condition. The goal is to develop a five-year cost comparison for replacing versus renting equipment and to determine the most efficient way to provide Tom with reliable equipment so maintenance work is not repeatedly interrupted by equipment failures.
19. Security / Gate Automation
The security report included an update on the automated gate. The membership-lane reader was expected to be installed/tested, and several different types of credentials/RFID emitters had been ordered.
Residents who frequently travel through the gate were asked to volunteer as test users. The goal was to test several vehicle types and credential placements and make sure the reader works reliably before full automation.
The board discussed the large stop sign and gate equipment. The automated gate is designed to close after the vehicle passes, and residents were reminded not to follow closely behind another vehicle through the gate.
A resident asked whether the gate would work with trailers. The board stated that the system was expected to account for trailers and that multiple sensors, including an in-ground pressure sensor, were involved. The board emphasized that testing was still underway and that the community would test different situations, including long trailers and other unusual cases.
20. Lake Safety / Security Incident
The president reported a recent lake-security incident involving four young males, one of whom was 18, who were on the lake during a severe storm. One person fell from the vessel, and the others initially moved away rather than returning to assist him. A resident observed the situation and urged them to retrieve the person.
The president emphasized that lake rules exist because serious accidents and drownings can occur and that the board does not want to have a future discussion about why more was not done to prevent an accident.
Residents were asked to educate guests, particularly younger guests, about the lake rules. The president specifically reviewed the requirement to keep the shoreline to the right while operating on the lake, the meaning of no-wake buoys, and the need to operate watercraft safely.
The board discussed concerns about alcohol use by young people on the lake and the need for parents and property owners to educate their guests. A prior incident was described in which a young person who had been drinking became disoriented and was later found walking along a road trying to obtain cell service.
The president stated that the community cannot function as a party destination without enforcing its rules and that the board intends to enforce the existing lake rules. Residents were invited to obtain copies of the rules if needed.
The board discussed warnings and fines. The president stated that residents generally receive a warning first and that a fine is the enforcement tool if a warning does not resolve the issue. The purpose of enforcement was described as safety rather than revenue.
The security committee has recruited residents to act as volunteer lake monitors. Volunteer security vests were obtained so that these volunteers can be recognized when helping educate residents and guests about safe lake behavior.
21. Dogs / Loose Animals
Amanda reported that the only animal matter reported during the month involved three stray puppies. Neighbors contributed toward a local rescue organization so the puppies could be safely removed from the community.
Amanda stated that loose-dog complaints must be submitted through the community reporting system with a photograph, date/time, and location. The current enforcement policy is a $100 fine for the first incident, doubling for subsequent incidents within a 12-month period. If multiple dogs are involved, the fine is applied per dog.
The board discussed the history of serious dog incidents in the community, including pets being killed and a child being attacked. Amanda stated that the policy would be enforced to protect children, elderly residents, walkers, joggers, and residents with pets.
The board distinguished between a dog that briefly gets loose while its owner is actively trying to retrieve it and an animal that is repeatedly allowed to roam or is involved in aggressive behavior.
A resident asked about the fine amount and recalled that the original amount had been lower. Amanda explained that the board had voted on the current policy approximately six months earlier.
22. Roads Committee
Wayne reported that several previously identified road areas had been repaired and that gravel had been spread on various roads.
Additional work was planned to fill potholes with asphalt. Locust Road was discussed as temporarily closed because of erosion, with repairs and drainage work planned. A resident on the road still had access.
The board discussed the need to address additional drainage and erosion areas and the possibility of using an outside contractor. The community has been setting aside approximately $50,000 annually for road work and may use some of those funds to address significant road hazards.
The board discussed a particular property/road location requiring attention and agreed to contact the vendor to determine how quickly the work could be addressed.
23. Water Committee
Donna reported that the Water Committee had met and discussed ways to improve water-department operations. Tom’s workload and the need for additional labor or volunteer assistance were discussed.
The committee planned to meet again on Thursday afternoon to discuss how volunteers could help, including assistance with meter work and other tasks. The goal is to make better use of available volunteers and provide additional support when needed.
24. Staff / Club Reports
The board noted that the security staff report was largely duplicative of the security committee report and that this section of the meeting format may need to be modified.
The Ladies’ Club meeting was discussed, with the meeting date identified as the 22nd. The Men’s Club was expected to meet the following morning at approximately 9:00 a.m.
The Men’s Club’s annual fish fry/fundraiser was discussed. Tickets were being sold for $20, and residents were encouraged to invite friends because the proceeds are generally returned to the community.
The fountain renovation was noted as having been paid for.
The Maintenance Club/maintenance group was reported to be focusing on street signs, including repairing, replacing, and creating new signs, including replacement of stolen signs.
25. Marina Committee Report
Glenn reported that the Marina Committee had made progress toward increasing marina usage. A major current issue is stabilization of the marina.
The committee is coordinating with Tom regarding the appropriate time to stabilize the marina, particularly when the lake level is lowered. The goal is to stabilize the existing marina before making additional improvements.
The committee is also evaluating possibilities for using existing uncovered areas for pontoon and/or other watercraft storage.
The committee discussed protecting boats and vehicles from accidental damage and the importance of boat owners taking responsibility for properly securing their vessels and equipment.
Additional fishing areas are being considered because residents have requested more fishing opportunities on both the larger and smaller lakes. Residents with specific marina or fishing-space concerns were encouraged to contact Glenn.
26. Incident and Maintenance Reporting System
The president reminded residents that the community website provides an online system for submitting security incident reports and maintenance requests.
Examples of reportable incidents include loose dogs, missing or unauthorized stickers, unauthorized people on the lake, reckless driving, speeding, and similar issues. Maintenance requests can also be submitted through the system.
The board emphasized that posting a concern on Facebook is not the same as filing an official report. Reports submitted through the website enter the community’s tracking system and are sent to the appropriate security or office personnel.
Residents were encouraged to use the system because it allows the board and staff to track issues, determine patterns, and document responses. Reports request the resident’s name, address, description of the issue, date/time, and photographs when available.
27. Adjournment
With no further business, the presiding officer asked for a motion to adjourn. A motion was made and seconded. The meeting was adjourned.
Following the adjournment motion, watermelon was offered to attendees.
Appendix A — Items Requiring Follow-Up
• Confirm Jones Lake Management’s lake-treatment date and coordinate individual dock treatment sign-ups.
• Determine treatment options for the smaller lake and obtain an assessment of algae conditions there.
• Continue obtaining state/agency guidance regarding lake water, E. coli concerns, runoff, sediment, and long-term lake management.
• Develop a longer-term one- to three-year lake-management plan, including algae, sediment, runoff, vegetation, and grass-carp stocking.
• Confirm placement of the new mooring buoy near the marina and reinforce no-wake rules.
• Complete ARC clarification regarding approvals, contractor/site-plan requirements, and committee responsibilities.
• Consider a community-wide reminder to residents to review covenants and rules.
• Continue evaluating Community Involvement Committee projects, including a possible 5K, food-truck events, senior programming, and a smaller-lake kayak launch.
• Obtain pricing and plan installation of rubber gym flooring.
• Develop a gym equipment wish list and future replacement/upgrade plan.
• Install marina walkout bumpers/stoppers when received.
• Research marina/boat insurance requirements and responsibility for damage.
• Evaluate parking and signage near the lake/levee.
• Complete roadside mulching and visibility work.
• Develop a five-year maintenance-equipment replacement/rental analysis.
• Complete testing of automated gate readers, credentials, trailers, sensors, and timing before full automation.
• Continue lake-safety education and volunteer lake-monitor program.
• Continue enforcement of the loose-dog policy and online incident-reporting requirements.
• Proceed with identified road/erosion repairs and obtain contractor timing.
• Meet regarding additional water-department labor/volunteer support.
• Continue marina stabilization and evaluate additional storage/fishing areas.
Grand Valley Lakes — Board Meeting Full Discussion Record
